| Date | Name | Division | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 03/17/63 | Rt. Rev. Msgr. Stanislaus J. McGovern | Spring Valley | |
| 03/22/64 | Judge John F. Skahen | New City | |
| 03/21/65 | Patrick Casey | Division 1 | Haverstraw |
| 03/20/66 | Rt. Rev. Msgr. James M. Gilmartin | County Chaplin | |
| 03/19/67 | Robert Meehan | Division 4 | |
| 03/17/68 | Neil Lucey | Division 4 | New City |
| 03/23/69 | Peter Anderson | Division 4 | Suffern |
| 03/22/70 | Ray Sheridan | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/21/71 | Frank Geoghan | Division 4 | Suffern |
| 03/19/72 | Tim Finn | Division 5 | Orangeburg |
| 03/18/73 | Tom Murray | Division 5 | Blauvelt |
| 03/24/74 | Matthias Reilly | Division 5 | Blauvelt |
| 03/23/75 | Niel O’Sullivan | Division 5 | Pearl River |
| 03/21/76 | Martin Fogarty | Division 5 | Blauvelt |
| 03/20/77 | John Tracey | Division 5 | Demarest, NJ |
| 03/19/78 | John Devlin | Division 5 | Pearl River |
| 03/18/79 | John O’Grady | Division 5 | Sparkill |
| 03/23/80 | Nicholas Murphy | Division 5 | New City |
| 03/22/81 | Thomas O’Riordan | Division 1 | Stony Point |
| 03/21/82 | Connie Smith | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/20/83 | Jack Connolly | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/18/84 | Rt. Rev. Msgr. James Cox | Division 5 | Orangeburg |
| 03/17/85 | John Foody | Division 5 | Blauvelt |
| 03/23/86 | John Scanlon | Division 1 | Haverstraw |
| 03/22/87 | John Cawley | Division 5 | Nanuet |
| 03/20/88 | Tom Mooney | Division 3 | Orangeburg |
| 03/19/89 | Connie O’Sullivan | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/18/90 | Patricia Dwyer | Division 1 | Stony Point |
| 03/17/91 | Danny Withers | Division 1 | Suffern |
| 03/22/92 | Frank O’Rourke | Division 5 | Valley Cottage |
| 03/21/93 | Fr. Peter Lappin,S.D.B. | County Chaplin | |
| 03/20/94 | Pat Moroney | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/19/95 | Ed Moane | Division 5 | Pearl River |
| 03/17/96 | Peg Matone | Division 1 | Thiells |
| 03/23/97 | Judge William Kelly | Division 2 | New City |
| 03/22/98 | James Normoyle | Division 1 | Stony Point |
| 03/20/99 | Denis Troy | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/19/00 | Gerry Walsh | Division 2 | WestNyack |
| 03/18/01 | F. Wilson Smith | Division 1 | Haverstraw |
| 03/17/02 | Brian Pearson | Division 5 | Pearl River |
| 03/23/03 | Jack O’Connor | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/24/04 | Mike Halpin | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/20/05 | Cyril Hughes | Division 1 | Nanuet |
| 03/19/06 | Jimmy Teague | Division 5 | Blauvelt |
| 03/18/07 | Mary O’Sullivan | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 03/9/08 | State Senator Thomas P. Morahan | Division 2 | New City |
| 03/22/09 | Terry Greenan | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 3/21/2010 | May Kreider | LAOH Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 3/20/2011 | Tim O’Neill | Division 1 | Stony Point |
| 3/18/2012 | Raymond Sheridan | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 3/17/2013 | Monsignor Edward Weber | County Chaplain | Stony Point |
| 3/23/2014 | Jim McDonnell | Division 1 | Stony Point |
| 3/22/2015 | Vincent Tyer | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 3/20/2016 | Dermot Moore | Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 3/19/2017 | Carmel Reilly | LAOH Division 3 | Pearl River |
| 3/19/2018 | Emmett Woods | AOH Division 5 | Pearl River |